Advertisement

QSR vs. value grocer:
Who’s winning with consumers?

Grocery cart in a grocery store
BY: Mari Rydings

Mari Rydings

KANSAS CITY, MO — Budget-minded consumers with bank accounts that have been affected by tariffs, inflation and the government shutdown are seeking “innovative value” and moving away from QSRs toward value grocers, dollar stores, c-stores and warehouse.

“Those are the four categories that are putting pressure on QSR for lower- to middle-income consumers,” said R.J. Hottovy, head of analytic research for Placer.ai, during the recent Q4 Crunch Time: Foodservice Foot Traffic & Trend Insights webinar hosted by The Food Institute. “Food-forward convenience stores such as Buckee’s, Wawa, Sheetz, QuikTrip and Casey’s — the ones that have really invested in the food program, mobile ordering, delivery and drive-thru windows — are taking the baton from QSR and taking leadership roles in terms of innovation while doing it with competitive pricing.”

Hottovy said Placer.ai data shows that middle- to upper-income consumers — the core of fast-casual dining — are also pulling back on their visit frequency and/or looking for less expensive alternatives, often turning to other channels.

Private label drives product innovation

Price sensitivity is driving this shift from food-away-from-home toward food-at-home, and it’s creating opportunities for bakeries in grocery stores, c-stores and other channels.

“We’re starting to see a pickup in fresh and specialty format grocers such as Sprouts, Whole Foods and Fresh Market,” Hottovy said. “Our data shows a pickup at lunchtime, with a big uptake at specialty grocers among stay-at-home workers. That’s a trend that’s become a story over the last three to four months.”

Grocery sales are up, with private label taking most of the share. One big reason for the rise in popularity of value grocers, aside from the stable price points, is the number of new product launches.

“With private label, you can move a lot faster sometimes in terms of product innovation,” Hottovy said. “With that flexibility to come up with a new flavor or a different type of SKU, it’s a combination of private label pricing and product innovation. That’s where a lot of the excitement in the category is happening.”

Advertisement

Is nostalgia on the outs?

Some of the success fast-casual dining has had this year comes from limited-time offers and nostalgia-based products. Hottovy predicts an end to that trend, and considering many foodservice trends trickle down to commercial baking, it’s a prediction bakers should take note of.

“There will be a breaking point with nostalgia. You can’t just flood the market with it. There will be a tipping point where consumers say, ‘This is just too much.’”
— R.J. Hottovy | head of analytic research | Placer.ai

Advertisement

“I think there will be a breaking point with nostalgia,” he said. “You can’t just flood the market with that. There will be a tipping point where consumers say, ‘This is just too much.’ You have to be disciplined in your approach.”

Advertisement

As the US trudges through a period of economic uncertainty, Hottovy believes QSR and fast-casual venues will continue facing negative foot traffic as consumers tighten their budgets. Bakers are well positioned to offer the “innovative value” wary shoppers are searching for.

Related News

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Popular Articles